Indianapolis Indians '47 Cap vs. New Era Cap: Which Fits Better?

Quick Answer

If you prefer a relaxed, adjustable fit that molds to your head, the '47 Clean Up cap is a great choice. If you want a structured, stretch-fit cap that feels snug and secure, the New Era 39THIRTY is likely your best bet. For most fans, the deciding factor comes down to whether you like a low-profile, unstructured look or a more traditional, structured crown.

When you're cheering on the Indianapolis Indians at Victory Field, the right cap does more than complete your outfit—it keeps you comfortable through nine innings. Two popular choices are the '47 Clean Up and the New Era 39THIRTY. Both offer quality and style, but they fit differently. Understanding those differences helps you pick the cap that feels like it was made for you.

In this comparison, we'll break down the key features of each cap, explain the trade-offs, and give you practical advice on which one to choose based on your head shape and preferences. We'll also highlight two specific models you can find at the Indianapolis Indians Official Online Store.

Understanding Cap Fits: Structured vs. Unstructured

The biggest difference between these two caps comes down to structure. The New Era 39THIRTY is a structured cap with a high crown that holds its shape. It's designed to sit firmly on your head, providing a classic baseball silhouette. The '47 Clean Up, on the other hand, is unstructured with a low crown. It has a relaxed, broken-in feel that conforms to your head over time.

Your head shape plays a big role in which fit you'll prefer. If you have a rounder head, a structured cap like the 39THIRTY might feel too tight or leave gaps. An unstructured cap like the '47 Clean Up often drapes more naturally. If you have a longer or more oval head, the structured crown of the 39THIRTY can provide a more secure, balanced fit.

• Structured caps (New Era) hold their shape and offer a classic, firm fit.
• Unstructured caps ('47) are relaxed and mold to your head over time.
• Consider your head shape: rounder heads often prefer unstructured, oval heads often suit structured.

Adjustability and Comfort: Strap vs. Stretch Fit

The way a cap adjusts affects both fit and comfort. The '47 Clean Up uses an adjustable fabric strap with a snap buckle. This lets you fine-tune the fit to your exact head size. It's a great option if you're between sizes or prefer a custom fit. The strap is made of fabric, which can be more comfortable against the skin than plastic snaps.

The New Era 39THIRTY uses a stretch-fit design. This means it has no closure; instead, the cap stretches to fit your head. This provides a snug, secure feel that doesn't loosen during wear. It also eliminates any pressure points from a strap. However, stretch-fit caps are less adjustable, so you need to choose the right size. If you're between sizes, you may need to try both to find the best fit.

• '47 Clean Up: adjustable fabric strap with snap buckle – good for fine-tuning fit.
• New Era 39THIRTY: stretch-fit – offers a snug, secure feel without a strap.
• If you value adjustability, go with '47; if you want a set-and-forget fit, choose New Era.

Crown Height and Brim Style

Crown height changes how a cap looks and feels. The '47 Clean Up has a low crown, which sits closer to your head and gives a more casual, vintage vibe. The brim is curved, which helps shield your eyes from the sun and adds to the relaxed look. This style is popular among fans who want a laid-back, everyday cap.

The New Era 39THIRTY features a higher, structured crown. This is the classic on-field look worn by players. The brim is also curved, but the overall profile is taller and more traditional. If you're used to wearing standard baseball caps, the 39THIRTY will feel familiar. If you prefer a lower-profile cap that doesn't add height to your head, the '47 is the way to go.

• Low crown ('47): sits closer to the head, casual look.
• High crown (New Era): traditional baseball profile, similar to on-field caps.
• Consider your style: '47 for a relaxed, vintage feel; New Era for a classic, sporty look.

Trade-Offs at a Glance

• Fit Adjustability: '47 Clean Up offers an adjustable strap, letting you customize the fit. New Era 39THIRTY uses stretch-fit, which is less adjustable but provides a consistent, snug feel. Choose '47 if you need adjustability; choose New Era if you prefer a set-and-forget fit.
• Crown Height: '47 has a low crown for a relaxed, casual look. New Era has a higher, structured crown for a traditional baseball profile. If you want a cap that sits close to your head, go with '47. If you like the classic on-field style, pick New Era.
• Comfort for Long Wear: Unstructured '47 caps are often more comfortable for all-day wear because they conform to your head. Structured New Era caps can feel more secure but may cause pressure points if the fit isn't perfect. For maximum comfort over many hours, '47 might be the safer bet; for a secure feel during active moments, New Era excels.

Two Caps to Consider

• Indianapolis Indians '47 Adult Navy Home Clean Up Adjustable Cap: This cap from '47 Brand features a 100% cotton material, low crown, unstructured relaxed fit, curved bill, and an adjustable fabric strap with snap buckle. It has a sublimated pattern and six-panel construction with embroidered eyelets. One size fits most. The unstructured, low-crown design gives a comfortable, relaxed fit that works well for all-day wear. The adjustable strap means you can dial in the perfect fit, even if your head size changes slightly.
• Indianapolis Indians Adult Native American Heritage New Era 39THIRTY Stretch Fit Cap: This New Era 39THIRTY cap is a Player Replica with a premier stretch-fit design. It features raised embroidered graphics and is the official replica of the cap worn by MLB players. The stretch-fit construction provides a snug, secure fit that stays in place during active moments. As a replica of the on-field cap, it offers an authentic look for fans who want to match their favorite players.

Which Cap Should You Choose?

Best For

• Fans who prefer a relaxed, low-profile fit that molds to their head.
• Those who want the ability to adjust the fit with a strap.
• People with rounder head shapes who find structured caps uncomfortable.

Not For

• Fans who want a structured, traditional baseball cap that holds its shape.
• Those who prefer a snug, stretch-fit without any strap or closure.
• People with larger head sizes who need a specific size rather than one-size-fits-most.

Both the '47 Clean Up and the New Era 39THIRTY are excellent Indianapolis Indians caps, each with its own strengths. The '47 offers a relaxed, adjustable fit that's perfect for casual wear, while the New Era provides a structured, secure fit for a classic on-field look. Consider your head shape, style preference, and how you plan to wear the cap. Try both to see which one feels better—your game-day comfort is worth it.