Two Navy Indians Caps, Two Different Feels
Both the Trawler Clean Up and the MVP are adult navy adjustable caps from '47, but they are built for different preferences. The Trawler Clean Up is a relaxed, curved snapback made from garment-washed cotton twill and soft mesh. The MVP is a structured, low-crown cap with a curved bill, a sublimated pattern and an adjustable velcro fabric strap.
If you want a broken-in look and feel, lean toward the Clean Up. If you prefer a cap that holds its shape and has a more textured look, the MVP is the better match. Neither is objectively better—it comes down to how you want the hat to sit and wear.
What the Catalog Confirms
- Indianapolis Indians '47 Adult Navy Home Trawler Clean Up Adjustable Cap: Relaxed and curved adjustable snapback with raised embroidery on the front. The relaxed build and snapback closure give the Clean Up a casual, easygoing fit.

Indianapolis Indians '47 Adult Navy Home Trawler Clean Up Adjustable Cap - Indianapolis Indians '47 Adult Navy Home Trawler Clean Up Adjustable Cap: Made from garment washed cotton twill and soft mesh. Garment washing softens the fabric from the start, while mesh adds breathability.
- Indianapolis Indians '47 Adult Navy Home MVP Adjustable Cap: Low crown, structured fit, curved bill. The structured low crown keeps a defined shape and sits closer to the head.

Indianapolis Indians '47 Adult Navy Home MVP Adjustable Cap - Indianapolis Indians '47 Adult Navy Home MVP Adjustable Cap: Adjustable velcro fabric strap; one size fits most. Velcro offers quick, fine-tuned adjustment without a plastic snap.
Fit and Structure: Relaxed vs Structured
The biggest difference is how each cap holds its shape. The Trawler Clean Up is described as relaxed, so it will likely feel softer and less rigid. The MVP is explicitly structured with a low crown, meaning it keeps a firmer shape and sits lower on the head.
- Trawler Clean Up: Relaxed, curved adjustable snapback. The soft mesh and garment-washed cotton twill suggest a broken-in feel from day one.
- MVP: Structured fit with a low crown and curved bill. The six-panel construction with embroidered eyelets adds definition.
Closure and Adjustability
Both caps are adjustable, but the hardware differs. The Clean Up uses a plastic snap closure, which is familiar and easy to use. The MVP uses a velcro fabric strap, which allows quick, stepless adjustment. Neither closure is inherently better; it's a matter of preference.
- Trawler Clean Up: Plastic snap closure—classic snapback style with discrete size settings.
- MVP: Velcro fabric strap—quick, fine-tuned adjustment with a fabric look.
Fabric and Breathability
The Trawler Clean Up combines garment-washed cotton twill with soft mesh. The washing process softens the twill, and the mesh panels add ventilation. The MVP is made from 80% acrylic and 20% cotton, a blend that holds its shape and supports the structured fit. The catalog does not specify mesh panels for the MVP, so if breathability is a priority, the Clean Up's mesh is a clearer choice.
Style and Detailing
The Clean Up has raised embroidery on the front and a clean, washed look. The MVP features a sublimated pattern across the cap, raised embroidery, and a six-panel construction with embroidered eyelets. Both are officially licensed, but only the MVP record explicitly states that. The MVP's patterned design makes a bolder statement, while the Clean Up keeps it simple and classic.
Price and Value
At the catalog prices shown, the Trawler Clean Up is USD 20.48 (compared to a USD 32.00 comparison price), and the MVP is USD 23.10 (compared to USD 35.00). Both offer a discount from the comparison price, but the Clean Up is the lower-priced option. If budget is a key factor, the Clean Up saves you a few dollars.
Which One Fits Your Game-Day Plan?
Choose the Trawler Clean Up if you want a soft, relaxed cap with mesh breathability and a classic snapback closure. It's a good pick for everyday wear and warm weather. Choose the MVP if you prefer a structured, low-crown fit with a velcro strap and a patterned look that stands out. Both are one-size adjustable, so your decision really comes down to the feel and style you want on your head.



